Thursday, January 19, 2012

Eastman Kodak files for bankruptcy protection

Eastman Kodak, the company that invented the hand-held camera, has filed for bankruptcy protection.

The move gives the company time to reorganise itself without facing its creditors, and Kodak said that it would mean business as normal for customers.

The company has recently moved away from cameras to focus on making printers, to try to stem its losses.

The 133-year-old firm has struggled to keep up with competitors who were quicker to adapt to the digital era.

"Kodak made all its money from selling film, then the digital camera came along and now no-one's buying film. It's not like they didn't see it coming. Kodak hesitated because they didn't want to eviscerate their business," said Rupert Goodwins, editor of technology website ZDNet.

Announcing the move to seek bankruptcy protection, Antonio Perez, Kodak's chairman and chief executive, said: "The board of directors and the entire senior management team unanimously believe that this is a necessary step and the right thing to do for the future of Kodak."

Kodak moments

Kodak box camera 1950
  • Kodak founder George Eastman produced the first camera film in rolls in 1883
  • The firm Kodak is set up in 1888 and launches the first consumer camera in 1888 with the slogan: "You press the button, we do the rest"
  • In 1900 Kodak introduces a consumer camera for $1 called the Brownie, which goes on to become a best-seller in America
  • In 1969 a Kodak camera is used during the first Moon landing
  • Kodak claims to have invented the world's first digital camera in 1975. It had a resolution of 0.1 megapixels; the camera was the size of a toaster

The company said it had already arranged a $950m (£615m) credit facility from Citigroup to keep it going.

The bankruptcy protection move by Kodak affects its operations and companies in the US, but the company said its non-US subsidiaries were not included in the move and would continue to operate as usual.

Its shares were suspended following the announcement. They last traded at 36 cents per share.

Kodak's shares have been in decline over the past decade. It fell out of the Dow Jones Industrial Average of 30 top US companies in 2004. That year, its shares were around $30 each.

Transformation

Since becoming chief executive, Mr Perez has been responsible for steering Kodak away from its traditional market in cameras to focus on home and commercial printers and he reiterated the hope that its "breakthrough" printing technologies would give it a competitive advantage as it tries to get back on track.

The firm said earlier this year that it was pinning its hopes on its printer, software and packaging businesses, with the aim of expanding them to account for 25% of its income by 2013. But some analysts remain to be convinced.

"Even though film and developing is a dead business, there is still money to be made in ink and other supplies," technology commentator Larry Magib told BBC World.

Steven Sasson with his prototype digital camera.

"But Hewlett Packard, Canon and Epson have those markets. Kodak does have printers, but it has not been able to succeed in making money from them," he said.

The move to seek bankruptcy protection comes after Kodak failed to sell its catalogue of digital imaging patents last year. At the time, Kodak warned that it would run out of cash if it did not find a buyer by the end of 2011.

It has struggled as mobile phone manufacturers have introduced increasingly sophisticated cameras on their own devices. This has had a huge impact on the lower end of the digital camera market, which Kodak concentrated on.

Kodak is also hoping to make the most of its technology patents involving digital capture, which is used in mobile phones and other portable gadgets. Kodak says these have generated $3bn in revenue since 2003.

Advertisement

Rupert Goodwins, ZD Net UK: "They knew what was happening, but they didn't have the guts to move with it"

On Wednesday, Kodak launched a lawsuit against Samsung, alleging that certain Samsung tablet devices infringe Kodak's digital imaging technology. The South Korean firm said the claims were "unsubstantiated".

It comes a week after Kodak launched a similar lawsuit against HTC and Apple over patents related to digital imaging technology.

Reorganisation

Former Kodak vice president Don Strickland insists the firm's late entry into the digital market is a key factor in its recent troubles. He claims he left the company in 1993 after he failed to get backing from within the company to release a digital camera.

"We developed the world's first consumer digital camera and Kodak could have launched it in 1992.

"We could not get approval to launch or sell it because of fear of the cannibalisation of film," he told BBC News.

Crisis jargon buster
Use the dropdown for easy-to-understand explanations of key financial terms:
Chapter 11
The term for bankruptcy protection in the US. It postpones a company's obligations to its creditors, giving it time to reorganise its debts or sell parts of the business, for example.

Although Kodak was one of the original inventors of digital photography, it failed to keep pace with developments in the market and competitors steadily eroded its share of the market.

Since 2003, Kodak has closed down 13 manufacturing plants and cut its workforce by 47,000 and there could be more cuts to come.

"Now we must complete the transformation by further addressing our cost structure and effectively monetising non-core IP assets," the Kodak chief executive said on Thursday.

Kodak employs 19,000 workers, but it is not known how many may be affected by the reorganisation.

In its 1980s heyday, the company employed 145,000 people in locations throughout the world.

Mr Strickland believes the firm has little chance of surviving long term.

"There will be no more 'Kodak moments' - after 133 years, the company has run its course."

Others think it may now be a takeover target.

"It is more likely someone will buy them out for their patents, for their intellectual property," technology journalist Kevin Anderson told BBC World.

"Google has been on a buying spree lately, buying up companies for patents. I don't think they will be in the market for them [Kodak], but that might be one attractive element for a potential buyer," he said.

What are your earliest memories of Kodak? Have you worked for Kodak? Share your Kodak moments with us today with your photos or anecdotes.

Hrant Dink: Istanbul march as verdict anger continues

Marchers carried placards reading "We are all Hrant, we are all Armenian"

Related Stories

At least 20,000 people have marched in Istanbul to mark five years since the murder of prominent Turkish-Armenian journalist Hrant Dink.

Some of the demonstrators were driven by anger over verdicts delivered this week in the latest trial of people linked to his killing.

Three people were jailed but allegations of official negligence or state collusion were rejected.

Dink's actual killer, Ogun Samast, was jailed earlier for 22 years.

The journalist, shot dead outside the Istanbul offices of Turkish-Armenian newspaper Agos, had angered Turkish nationalists by describing the mass killing of Armenians a century ago as genocide.

Start Quote

The Dink case is not a file that can be closed. The Dink case is a wound”

End Quote Karin Karakaslı Ethnic Armenian journalist

On Tuesday, a judge sentenced one man to life imprisonment for incitement to murder Dink, and two others were given 12 years in prison.

However, all three men, along with 16 other defendants, were acquitted of the charge of being members of a criminal organisation.

The prosecutor, Hikmet Usta, said he would appeal against Judge Rustem Eryilmaz's decision, and insisted there was sufficient evidence to establish the murder had been an "organised crime".

Turkish President Abdullah Gul defended the verdicts of the court on Thursday, saying "The conclusion of this case in a transparent and just manner in line with our laws is an important test for us."

'We are all Armenian'

On Thursday, human rights activists placed red carnations on the spot where Dink was shot dead by Samast in broad daylight, outside the offices of Agos.

Dink's widow Rakel and his children were among the demonstrators, many of whom carried placards reading "We are all Hrant, we are all Armenian".

Red carnations surround a photo of Hrant Dink outside the Agos newspaper offices in Istanbul, 19 January Red carnations surrounded a photo of Hrant Dink outside the Agos offices

Journalist and writer Karin Karakasli, an ethnic Armenian, read out a statement from the window of the Agos offices.

"We want an end to this shame," she was quoted as saying by Turkish newspaper Today's Zaman.

"They are telling us that the [case] file has been closed. The Dink case is not a file that can be closed. The Dink case is a wound."

A smaller march was also held in the capital, Ankara, and rallies and tributes to Dink were reported in other Turkish cities such as Izmir and Bursa, and as far away as the Green Line in Cyprus.

Among those attending the Istanbul rally was prominent Turkish writer Vedat Turkali, 92, who appeared in his wheelchair.

Dink's supporters say they have uncovered evidence that suggests involvement by state officials and police in his murder.

But, they say, repeated requests to have those officials investigated have been ignored, and in some cases important evidence has been destroyed.

'Not thorough'

In his petition against the verdict, Prosecutor Usta pointed out that, in his initial verdict, Judge Eryilmaz had left out one of the 19 defendants, thus acquitting only 18.

He said the fact that the judge had left out a suspect indicated that the indictment had not been thoroughly examined.

Start Quote

This is the only decision we could take, according to the available evidence”

End Quote Judge Rustem Eryilmaz Responding to his own verdict

Sources quoted by Today's Zaman said the omission had been accidental, and the 19th defendant's acquittal was being announced separately.

Judge Eryilmaz has expressed doubts about his own verdict, saying that any "connections" between the culprits and the state could not be clearly established before the trial.

"However, this is the only decision we could take, according to the available evidence," he told the private news channel NTV.

The European Court of Human Rights ruled in 2010 that Turkey had failed to protect Dink, despite being warned that ultra-nationalists were plotting to kill him.

The court also criticised Turkish authorities over the investigation of his murder.

The Turkish state strenuously denies that the deaths of hundreds of thousands of Armenians in 1915-16 amounted to genocide.

Armenians say as many as 1.5 million people were slaughtered or died of starvation and disease when they were deported by the Ottoman Turks.

Phone hacking: Jude Law, Lord Prescott and Sara Payne get payouts

Jude Law and Lord Prescott are among the latest people given payouts over phone hacking by the News of the World.

Actor Law received the highest payout of £130,000 ($200,000). The ex-deputy PM got £40,000, the High Court heard.

Sara Payne, mother of murdered schoolgirl Sarah, and Shaun Russell, whose wife and daughter were murdered in 1996, were given undisclosed sums.

News International apologised in court but later said senior staff knew nothing about the wrongdoing.

As details emerged of 37 cases - of which 19 were newly-settled - lawyers said most people pursuing damages had now reached agreements out of court.

Law's phone was repeatedly hacked between 2003 and 2006. His ex-wife Sadie Frost - who received a £50,000 payout - said she had distrusted him because journalists always knew where she would be, the court heard.

Analysis

A packed court, standing room only, heard 18 statements read out by victims of phone-hacking. Each time the media company admitted its guilt, it offered "its sincerest apologies" and paid up in damages

Actress Sadie Frost, who got £50,000, said journalists always seemed to know where she was. She suspected her husband, actor Jude Law, was leaking information. This was a common theme, highlighting the distrust among friends and families that hacking created.

Another major concern was the breach of security the practice created. Joan Hammell, special adviser to John Prescott, was cleared to the highest security level because she was privy to "highly sensitive information", but was hacked anyway. Damages £40,000

The only hacking victim in court was Chris Bryant MP who stood calmly with his arms crossed as News International apologised.

These cases are the bulk of those outstanding, but 10 cases may still go to trial.

In a statement issued after the hearing, Law said: "I was suspicious about how information concerning my private life was coming out in the press.

"I changed my phones, I had my house swept for bugs but still the information kept being published. I started to become distrustful of people close to me."

In total 16 articles were published containing Law's personal information. His personal assistant Ben Jackson was also awarded £40,000, while his public relations consultant Ciara Parkes got £35,000.

The News of the World had placed Mr Prescott under surveillance, the court heard.

The peer told the Hull Daily Mail the settlement "brought clarity, apology and compensation" and followed years of "aggressive denials and a cavalier approach to private information and the law".

Other payouts included an undisclosed sum to footballer Ashley Cole, £40,000 to Welsh rugby union star Gavin Henson (the former partner of singer Charlotte Church) and the same sum to entrepreneur and friend of Princes William and Harry, Guy Pelly.

Mr Pelly said in a statement read in court he had phoned his voicemail to find it engaged.

The judge heard statements on behalf of 18 of the 37. It is expected more will follow at a later date.

No statement was read for Ms Payne, from Surrey, who became a child protection campaigner after her daughter's murder in West Sussex in 2000. Likewise for Mr Russell, from Gwynedd, whose wife Lyn and daughter Megan were attacked with a hammer in a Kent country lane.

'Utmost distress'

BBC legal correspondent Clive Coleman said some commentators were viewing the latest settlements as News International "waving the white flag".

There did not seem to be a huge appetite on News International's part to put journalists and editors in the witness box, he said.

The company issued what it called a "clarification" about the settlements later on Thursday on behalf of its subsidiary News Group Newspapers (NGN).

It said: "NGN made no admission as part of these settlements that directors or senior employees knew about the wrongdoing by NGN or sought to conceal it.

Advertisement

Victims' lawyer Tamsin Allen: They now know who accessed their voicemail messages

"However, for the purpose of reaching these settlements only, NGN agreed that the damages to be paid to claimants should be assessed as if this was the case."

Clive Coleman said payouts varied according to the number of times a phone had been hacked and over what period, the extent of intrusion and number of articles published.

"The Metropolitan Police have said there were around 800 victims of phone hacking. Potentially each of those victims has a claim to bring," he added.

Labour MP Chris Bryant, who was awarded £30,000, said in a court statement it was "a matter of utmost distress" to discover he was a victim.

Joan Hammell, chief of staff to Lord Prescott, was awarded £40,000. She was party to highly sensitive information and cleared to the highest security vetting level within government, the court heard.

Christopher Shipman, son of serial killer Dr Harold Shipman, was awarded an undisclosed fee after his e-mails and phone were hacked.

Other payouts confirmed at Thursday's hearing included:

  • £30,000 to Lisa Gower, who was in a relationship with comedian Steve Coogan
  • £25,000 to Ashley Cole's solicitor, Graham Shear
  • £25,000 to freelance crime reporter Tom Rowland
  • £32,500 to Labour MP Denis McShane
  • Undisclosed damages to former Labour MP Claire Ward
  • £27,500 to journalist and author Joan Smith
  • £60,000 to an anonymous claimant

Other cases among the 37 concerned TV presenter Ulrika Jonsson, former FA chief David Davies, ex-cavalry officer James Hewitt, who had an affair with Diana, Princess of Wales, ex-MP George Galloway, former cabinet minister Tessa Jowell, singer Dannii Minogue and her brother Brendan.

Settlement figures were not mentioned, nor in the cases of Paul Dadge, who helped survivors of the 7/7 London bombings, ex-Lib Dem MP Mark Oaten, celebrity Abi Titmuss, Calum Best, son of George Best, and Meg Matthews, ex-wife of former Oasis guitarist Noel Gallagher.

The remaining settlements involve figures named as Michelle Milburn, Colette Bos, police officer Dan Lichters, Cornelia Crisan, and Lance Gerrard-Wright, former husband of Ulrika Jonsson.

'Extremely brave'

Mark Thomson, of Atkins Thomson, told Thursday's hearing other claimants had not settled and would press ahead with a trial scheduled for next month.

The case involving Charlotte Church is among 10 as yet unsettled which are to be tried on 13 February in a hearing designed to provide a framework for the level of compensation due in any future cases.

Lord Prescott Lord Prescott had been placed under surveillance by the News of the World

"All of the claimants have been extremely brave to take on and succeed against a massive and influential multinational media organisation," said Mr Thomson.

Private detective Glenn Mulcaire, who was jailed in 2007 for illegally accessing voicemails while contracted to the News of the World, was a second defendant in each of the cases.

However, the court heard he was not involved in any of the settlements, nor party to any of the statements, because he has been arrested as part of the Metropolitan Police's phone-hacking investigation.

Dozens of Tuareg rebels dead in Mali clash, says army

Forty-five Tuareg rebels have been killed in two days of fierce clashes with Mali's government troops, the country's military says.

It says that two soldiers also died in the fighting in the vast desert area of northern Mali.

Some of the rebels have returned from Libya where they had been part of Col Muammar Gaddafi's security forces.

The Tuareg are calling for an autonomous Azawad region in the north of Mali.

"The attackers suffered heavy losses," Mali's defence ministry said in a statement on Thursday.

It said several vehicles were destroyed during the clashes, and three towns in the desert - including Tessalit and Aguel'hoc- were now under the army's control.

At least eight people - including government troops - were injured.

The rebels were members of the the newly formed National Movement for the Liberation of Azawad (NLMA), the ministry added.

The rebels have not publicly commented on the statement.

Map

The BBC's Martin Vogl, in the capital, Bamako, says that these new rebels are heavily armed and well-trained fighters.

They returned to Mali after Libya's uprising - after spending years fighting for Col Gaddafi, who was overthrown and killed by rebel forces last year.

This week's clashes ended several years of fragile peace in the region.

The Tuareg are a nomadic community who mostly live in northern Mali, northern Niger and southern Algeria.

In Mali, they have long complained that they have been marginalised by the southern government and have staged several rebellions over the years.

Israel arrests senior Palestinian Aziz Dweik

A senior Palestinian politician and member of the militant group Hamas has been arrested by the Israeli army in the West Bank.

Aziz Dweik, speaker of the Palestinian Legislative Council (PLC), was arrested at an army checkpoint, his chief of staff told AFP news agency.

The arrest happened in Jaba between Ramallah and Jerusalem as Dr Dweik was travelling by car to Hebron, Bhaa Youssef said.

Israel has confirmed the arrest.

Israeli border troops said he was detained for "involvement in terrorist activities".

Witnesses told the Palestinian Maan news agency that Israeli soldiers handcuffed and blindfolded Dr Dweik before taking him to an unknown destination.

Dr Dweik is a member of the Islamist Hamas movement, which governs the Palestinian territory of Gaza. However, he is based in the West Bank.

The Palestinian parliament has not met since Hamas seized control of Gaza in 2007 from the rival Palestinian Fatah Party.

Since then Fatah - backed by the West - governs the West Bank.

Map locator

The BBC's Wyre Davies in Jerusalem says Aziz Dweik has remained an influential figure in Palestinian political circles.

Many will see his arrest as a provocative act and further proof than Israel is pursuing a policy of restricting the movements of senior Palestinian figures, he adds.

The arrest comes amid rising tensions between Israel and Gaza. On Wednesday Israeli aircraft attacked targets in Gaza and troops struck targets near the border fence between Gaza and Israel.

Last May, Dr Dweik was held at an Israeli military checkpoint in the West Bank along with three other Hamas MPs.

One of the group, Nizar Ramadan, was detained but the others were allowed to proceed.

Analysts say about 20 of Hamas's 74 MPs in the 132-member PLC are currently being held by Israel.

The majority, who include two former ministers, have been arrested in the West Bank since October 2010.

Last month Israel freed 550 Palestinian prisoners in the second and final phase of a deal that saw the release of Israeli soldier Gilad Shalit in October.

Sgt Shalit, 25, was seized in 2006 by Hamas militants who tunnelled into Israel.

Hamas is listed as a terrorist organisation by Israel, the US and EU, due to its refusal to renounce violence and recognise Israel. Under the group's charter, Hamas is committed to the destruction of Israel.

Megaupload file-sharing site shut down

Megaupload, one of the internet's largest file-sharing sites, has been shut down by officials in the US.

The site's founders have been charged with violating piracy laws.

Federal prosecutors have accused it of costing copyright holders more than $500m (£320m) in lost revenue. The firm says it was diligent in responding to complaints about pirated material.

The news came a day after anti-piracy law protests, but investigators said they were ordered two weeks ago.

The US Justice Department said that Megaupload's two co-founders Kim Dotcom, formerly known as Kim Schmitz, and Mathias Ortmann were arrested in Auckland, New Zealand along with two other employees of the business at the request of US officials. It added that three other defendants were still at large.

"This action is among the largest criminal copyright cases ever brought by the United States and directly targets the misuse of a public content storage and distribution site to commit and facilitate intellectual property crime," said a statement posted on its website.

Third-party sites

The charges included copyright infringement, conspiracies to commit racketeering, copyright infringement and money laundering.

A federal court in Virginia ordered that 18 domain names associated with the Hong Kong-based firm be seized.

The Justice Department said that more than 20 search warrants had been executed in nine countries, and that approximately $50m in assets had been seized.

It claimed that the accused had pursued a business model designed to promote the uploading of copyrighted works.

"The conspirators allegedly paid users whom they specifically knew uploaded infringing content and publicised their links to users throughout the world," a statement said.

"By actively supporting the use of third-party linking sites to publicise infringing content, the conspirators did not need to publicise such content on the Megaupload site.

"Instead, the indictment alleges that the conspirators manipulated the perception of content available on their servers by not providing a public search function on the Megaupload site and by not including popular infringing content on the publicly available lists of top content downloaded by its users."

Before it was shut down the site posted a statement saying the allegations against it were "grotesquely overblown".

"The fact is that the vast majority of Mega's internet traffic is legitimate, and we are here to stay," it added.

"If the content industry would like to take advantage of our popularity, we are happy to enter into a dialogue. We have some good ideas. Please get in touch."

Blackouts

The announcement came a day after thousands of websites took part in a "blackout" to protest against the Stop Online Piracy Act (Sopa) and the Protect Intellectual Property Act (Pipa).

The US Chamber of Commerce has defended the proposed laws saying that enforcement agencies "lack the tools" to effectively apply existing intellectual property laws to the digital world.

Industry watchers suggest this latest move may feed into the wider debate.

"Neither of the bills are close to being passed - they need further revision. But it appears that officials are able to use existing tools to go after a business alleged to be inducing piracy," said Gartner's media distribution expert Mike McGuire.

"It begs the question that if you can find and arrest people who are suspected to be involved in piracy using existing laws, then why introduce further regulations which are US-only and potentially damaging."

Costa Concordia: Crew 'admitted to blackout only'

Costa Concordia crew member tells coastguard "we have a blackout"

Cruise disaster

  • 'I never saw the captain'
  • What next for ship?
  • How safe are cruise ships?
  • How crash happened

Italian media have broadcast what they say is the first phone conversation between port officials and crew of the Costa Concordia as the cruise ship was starting to sink on Friday.

In the exchange, said to have taken place 30 minutes after the ship hit rocks, a crew member is heard saying it is experiencing only a blackout.

The vessel ran aground with some 4,200 people on board. At least 11 died.

The continuing search for the missing may be threatened by worsening weather.

The ship is lying on its side just off the Tuscan island of Giglio, but there are fears it could slip into deeper water.

Twenty-one people are still missing, and hopes to find any of them alive are fading fast.

List of dead and missing

  • Confirmed dead: Sandor Feher, Hungary, crew; French nationals Pierre Gregoire, Jeanne Gannard, Jean-Pierre Micheaud, Francis Servil, passengers; Italian Giovanni Masia, passenger; Spaniard Guillermo Gual, passenger; Peruvian Thomas Alberto Costilla Mendoza, crew.
  • Missing: 21 people plus three unidentified bodies. Nationalities as follows: 12 Germans, six Italians (including one crew member), two French, two Americans, one Peruvian (crew), one Indian (crew)

In the audio tape aired on Thursday, a port authority officer is heard asking the crewman about the situation on board, after passengers had reported a huge jolt and been told to put on life vests.

But an unidentified voice from the Costa Concordia replies: "We had a blackout and we are checking the conditions on board."

"Do you need help or are you staying in the Giglio area for now?" the port official asks.

"Confirmed. We remain here in the area to check the blackout," the crew member replies, without making any reference to a crash.

The BBC's Alan Johnston on Giglio says the impression left by the recording is that the crewman failed to give a full account of the gravity of the situation.

Woman sought

The ship's captain, Francisco Schettino, is under house arrest on suspicion of multiple manslaughter.

Advertisement

Moldovan passenger Domnica Cemortan: 'Passengers were like a herd of lost sheep'

The owners say he was sailing too close to Giglio on an unauthorised course.

Prosecutors have also accused him of fleeing the ship before evacuation was complete. He denies the accusations.

However Italian media have said Capt Schettino did admit to making a navigational error.

He told investigators he had "ordered the turn too late" as the luxury ship sailed close to an island, according to a leaked interrogation transcript.

He also reportedly said the crew had decided to sail close to the island to salute a former colleague.

The company that owns the ship, Costa Cruises, has suspended Capt Schettino and withdrawn an offer to pay his legal costs, according to reports.

Italian media have also shown pictures of a Moldovan woman who says she was on the bridge after the ship ran aground. The woman defended Capt Schettino's actions, in an interview with Moldovan TV.

The reports say investigators are trying to speak to her.

On Thursday, rescue workers continued their search of submerged parts on the ship, after the coastguard said the wreck had stabilised.

Salvage operators are standing by to start pumping fuel from the ship's tanks to avoid a potential environmental disaster.

Were you on the cruise ship? Are you still waiting to hear of news of your missing friend or relative? Are you involved in the rescue effort? Share your experiences.